2023
David Ayers- Butler University
Bryson Bethel- Morehouse College
Kyuss Gargett- University of Kentucky
2022
Nick Bassi- St. Charles College
Henry Birk- Wabash
Dylan Haslett- Oakland University
Jake Tomich- Wabash
Alexander Wright- George Washington
2021
Chris Gallagher- Wright State University
Nolan Hastings- Curry College
Camden Jordan- University of Louisville/San Jacinto College/Indiana (Football)
Will Phillips-Wabash
2020
Kyle Cortner- Lincoln Trail College/Indiana State
Cam Clark- Spalding University
2019
Peyton Schofield- University of Charleston Southern/Marshall
Mitch Bertrand- Wabash
Derek Haslett- Wabash
Sam Phillips- Wabash
Cole Vassilo- Wabash
2018
Jared Poland- University of Louisville
Alex Scherer- John A. Logan College/Southern Illinois Univ. Edwardsville
Evan Uhland- DePauw University
Mack Murphy- Ball State University
2017
Nick Eaton — Indiana/Butler
Jack Myers — Butler/Kennesaw State
Jack Phillips — Northern Illinois
2016
Nick Andriole — Dayton
Will Conway — Purdue
Brantley Johnson — Dayton
2015
Ashe Russell – Texas A&M (drafted by Royals)
Adam Neal – IPFW
Jack Schmidt – Wayne State
2014
Harry Shipley – Purdue
Alex Boos – Yale
Dorian Holmes – Earlham
2013
Austin Sparks – Cincinnati
Brendan Flood – Indiana
Mike Hammel – Indiana State
Will Birch – Bellarmine
Luke Cureton – Indiana
Chris Ward – Quincy
2012
Ryan Levenhagen – Army West Point
Matt Dauby – Virginia Tech
Nick McCarty – Notre Dame
Austin Boos – Illinois Tech
Mike Kseniak – Butler
Will Hunker – Heidelberg/Marian
2011
Phil Mosey – Notre Dame
Dillon Peters – Texas
2009
Patrick Paligraf – Xavier
Kevin Bower – Miami (Ohio)
Danny Leicht – Holy Cross
2008
Jack Lupo – Air Force and Vanderbilt
Justin Cureton – Indiana
Alex Wright – Depauw
Tyler Koors – Xavier
Brandon Stevens – Bradley
2007
Anthony Agnew – Indiana
Steve Darragh – Butler
2006
Brad Henke – Indiana
Jimmy Roesinger – Dayton
Patrick Coffey – Xavier
Scott O’Neil – Richmond
Cy Fraker – Vincennes/Carson Newman
2005
Tommy Hunter – Alabama
Andrew Madia – Purdue
Grant Thullen – Kentucky Wesleyan
2004
Nick Lyons – Wabash
2003
Matt Ferguson – Butler
Kevin Miller – Dayton
Pat Barmann – Saint Louis
2002
Joe McSoley – Dayton
Brian Bego – Tri-Central
Jeff Fontaine – Evansville
2001
Sam Sellery – Miami (Ohio)
Kyle Morrison – Hanover
Michael Lauck – Dayton
Nick Szymanski – Hanover
2000
Jake Fox – Michigan
1999
Eddie Freije – Dayton
Jimmy Cartwright – St. Joseph’s
1998
Tim Miller – Indiana/Dayton
Michael Woodside – Indiana
Zach Fox – Air Force/Dayton
